top of page

Impact of Water Body Restoration

In recent years, the environmental community has celebrated #phytoremediation as a promising technique for restoring polluted water bodies. Phytoremediation involves plants removing contaminants from #soil and #water, offering an ecologically friendly alternative to traditional cleanup methods. While phytoremediation has gained traction for its potential to mitigate pollution, it is essential to scrutinize its long-term impacts and potential drawbacks.


Makarba Lake, Ahmedabad
Makarba Lake, Ahmedabad. Credit: IndusInd Bank

It is becoming increasingly clear that this seemingly ideal solution may not be without its downsides.


1. Alteration of Ecological Balance:

Phytoremediation, while designed to improve #waterquality, can also lead to an unintended alteration of the ecological balance within water bodies. In some cases, introducing non-native plants for phytoremediation leads to out-competing indigenous species, which disrupts established food chains, degrades habitat quality, and even contributes to the loss of native species. Consequently, while we obtain the positive results of reduction in the primary #pollutants, overall #ecosystem health is compromised.


2. Limited Contaminant Uptake:

One of the main critiques of phytoremediation is its limited capacity to extract contaminants from #water bodies effectively. While certain plants have proven to accumulate pollutants, the process is slow and often insufficient for addressing extensive pollution levels. Phytoremediation becomes particularly concerning when dealing with severe #contamination scenarios, as the contaminant removal rate is less than the rate of pollution input.


3. Secondary Pollution Risks:

Phytoremediation can inadvertently create secondary pollution risks. As plants accumulate pollutants, the contaminants may remain stored within the #biomass. If not properly managed, the harvested plant material can release these contaminants back into the environment when decomposing. Further, various studies have shown the transferring of pollutants into the plant's #flowers, #fruits, or #seeds, potentially entering the #foodchain and causing harm to both #humans and #wildlife.


4. Limited Durability and Maintenance:

The long-term success of phytoremediation heavily relies on maintenance and continued care. If the plants responsible for pollutant removal are not managed appropriately or die off, the remediation process could stall or can be reversed, placing a significant burden on the management and upkeep of the restored water bodies, which might not always be feasible, especially in the face of changing environmental conditions.


5. Potential for Bioaccumulation:

Phytoremediation, though designed to remove pollutants, can inadvertently facilitate the process of #bioaccumulation, where pollutants become more concentrated as they move up the food chain, especially concerning when considering #heavymetals or persistent #organic pollutants. Organisms that feed on the plants used for phytoremediation could accumulate these pollutants in their tissues, potentially causing harm to predators higher up in the food chain, including humans.


6. Uncertainty in Long-Term Effects:

Perhaps the most significant challenge with phytoremediation is the uncertainty surrounding its long-term effects. Due to the relatively recent adoption of this technique, there is limited unbiased research on how water bodies treated with phytoremediation will evolve. Unintended consequences might manifest years or even decades after the initial implementation, making it challenging for the management to predict and mitigate potential negative impacts.


In conclusion, while phytoremediation holds promise as a sustainable method for restoring polluted water bodies, ignoring its long-term negative impacts can lead to #catastrophe. The alteration of #ecologicalbalance, limited contaminant uptake, the potential for secondary pollution, #maintenance requirements, bioaccumulation potential, and the uncertainty surrounding long-term effects all underscore the need for precautious consideration when employing phytoremediation as a solution.


It is imperative that environmental practitioners, policymakers, and researchers carefully weigh the benefits against the risks and seek a holistic understanding of the potential consequences before relying solely on this technique for water body restoration.


Get the per-feasibility report from EnviroChem Services before implementing the water body restoration. Only through a balanced and informed approach, the phytoremediation can truly achieve meaningful and lasting environmental improvement.

32 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page